It’s been a rough year for NFT (non-fungible token) investors. Between market constrictions, rug pulls and failed projects, many buyers are left holding assets that represent a considerable unrealized loss.
As the 2022 tax year comes to a close, NFT traders may hope to tax-loss harvest, or sell their assets at a loss in order to offset current or future capital gains. That, however, is easier said than done.
Zac McClure is the co-founder of TokenTax. This article is part of CoinDesk's Tax Week.
There are many reasons NFT tax-loss harvesting is a challenge. One is financial: Because each token is a unique asset, it is difficult to estimate what an NFT’s fair market value might be. This makes it hard to pinpoint which assets are the best opportunities for harvesting.
Crypto tax platforms, portfolio trackers and NFT valuators are rising to meet the challenge, allowing investors to get a better idea of the losses they could expect to lock in from the sale of underwater tokens.
A more intractable problem stems from market illiquidity, or in plainer terms from an asset being worthless. Many traders are holding NFTs for which there is no (or little to no) market. This could be the result of an NFT rug pull (like Frosties) or a project that simply didn’t make it (like Loot).
So how do you legally realize a loss on a worthless NFT? The Internal Revenue Service says one must sell an asset in an “arm’s length transaction.” This means a trade in which both parties are acting independently, in their own best interest and without any pressure from one another. Typically, this would mean that the involved parties have no prior relationship. Selling a token on an exchange is an example of an arm’s length transaction.
When an NFT has little to no value, finding an independently motivated buyer is difficult. Why would anyone pay you for something with no value? Some investors have tried to skirt the issue by burning worthless tokens, but there’s no guidance from the IRS to suggest the agency would consider this a valid way to realize losses; the asset didn’t transfer into someone else’s custody.
Other would-be tax-loss harvesters have set up reciprocal services. While the details of these arrangements vary, the basic idea is “you pay me 0.001 ETH for my worthless NFT and I’ll pay you 0.001 ETH for yours.”
Tax professionals warn that this kind of agreement doesn’t meet the criteria for being an arm’s length transaction – the parties established a prior relationship before conducting the trade.
See also: IRS Expands Key US Tax Language to Include NFTs
So, what’s a trader with an illiquid NFT to do? Unfortunately, there aren’t many answers. At this time, the best that crypto tax accountants can advise is to do all you can to sell the asset for a nominal sum on an exchange or in arm’s length transaction on a marketplace.
All in all, this is another example of the need for further federal guidance and regulation on digital assets. Until clarity is provided on if and how the IRS expects traders to realize losses on illiquid tokens, NFT tax-loss harvesting will remain one of the many murky gray areas of crypto tax.
Related Quotes
Barry Ritholtz thinks bear market anxieties are overblown
Ethereum, the pioneering blockchain for innovative technologies such as decentralized finance (DeFi) and NFTs, recently completed its much-anticipated Merge – sparking institutional interest and unlocking yield-generation opportunities via its proof-of-stake (POS) blockchain. At the same time, an October poll conducted by the Crypto Council for Innovation indicated that a majority of U.S. voters want more crypto regulation and believe that lawmakers should treat cryptocurrency as a serious and valid part of the economy. Especially as they relate to NFTs, staking and yield farming.
U.S. Senators are planning to push forward with the bipartisan Digital Commodities Consumer Protection Act (DCCPA) crypto legislation backed by Sam Bankman-Fried despite the implosion his crypto exchange FTX. "The Hash" panel discusses the potential outcomes and Bankman-Fried's political reach in the latest fallout.
The cryptocurrency exchange declared bankruptcy last Tuesday. Its former CEO has apparently still been trying to plug a shortfall of up to $8 billion.
NFTs, meaning Non-Fungible Tokens, is a concept that gets people together. From arts to music to exclusive content and to VIP events, the NFT ecosystem brings so much to users. Metaverse allows users to engage in real-life activities in virtual reality (VR). You can own clothes, buy shoes, and even own land. And this has enabled projects to transform from NFTs into the Metaverse. One such project that has transformed is the Million Dollar Metaverse – the first real estate company in the Metavers
A group of major banks have commenced a pilot project alongside the Federal Reserve Bank of New York to test the feasibility of using tokens representing digital dollars to improve how central bank money is settled between institutions.
Last year, NFT technology seemed poised to revolutionize the fine art market. Today, many are worthless. The post The Rise and Fall of NFT Art appeared first on Worth.
Test time. If you’re a professional drug trafficker, what’s your favorite way to move product in and around the U.S.? Is it…
The iconic brown Birkenstocks were sold with a matching digital collectible on the Polygon blockchain.
(Reuters) -Michael Barr, the Federal Reserve's top financial regulatory official, on Tuesday said he is concerned about risks from the non-bank sector, including cryptocurrencies, for which the U.S. central bank and other regulators have poor visibility. "We're concerned about the risks that we don't know about in the non-bank sector," Barr said in response to a question during an appearance before the Senate Banking Committee. Barr's remarks came in his first congressional testimony since becoming the Fed's top Wall Street cop over the summer and augmented his prepared comments to the committee that he was keeping a close eye for stresses in the financial system amid a weakening economy.
Both of these trends are good for cannabis real estate investment trusts (REITs) like AFC Gamma (NASDAQ: AFCG) and Industrial Properties (NYSE: IIPR). The two REITs are thriving. This is partly because with cannabis still on Schedule 1 under the Controlled Substances Act, banks generally won't provide full services to marijuana companies in the U.S. That means cannabis retailers, when they need capital, are more likely to turn to REITs for cash, typically is sale leaseback deals in which the seller gets funds while the REIT gets a long-term tenant.
Northrim (NRIM) could be a great choice for investors looking to make a profit from fundamentally strong stocks that are currently on the move. It is one of the several stocks that made it through our "Recent Price Strength" screen.
ConsenSys Head Economist Lex Sokolin discusses the FTX collapse and impact on the crypto industry, saying it's a "confidence crisis in the ecosystem as a whole." While the continued fallout from the now-bankrupt exchange is weighing on crypto prices, Sokolin argues, "prices are not the end goal."
Police say the victim was shot in the leg as he attempted to run away.
The swift and surprising collapse of FTX last week continues to send shockwaves across the crypto industry and beyond – and Capitol Hill is not immune.
Yakoa, an NFT fraud detection startup, has raised $4.8 million to build tools to fight intellectual property fraud in web3, the company exclusively told TechCrunch. One of the most common attacks Yakoa sees is people making copies of NFTs and claiming them as their own work, Andrew Dworschak, co-founder of the startup, said. Yakoa provides tools and an indexer that detects copies or infringement probabilities on original NFTs, ranging from direct forgery to partial or stylistic forgery, which will then notify platforms, brands or creators of these fraudulent activities.
Investors have removed large quantities of bitcoin and ethereum from centralised cryptocurrency exchanges such as Coinbase, Binance and Crypto.com in the wake of the FTX bankruptcy.
The second of two suspects in the burglary of a jewelry store was captured about 2:30 a.m. The other suspect was captured Monday.
The ex-CEO of bankrupt crypt exchange FTX claims liquidity, not insolvency, is the issue.
SALT is the latest crypto company caught up in fhe contagion sparked by the fall of Sam Bankman-Fried's empire.
